Why Retail's Biggest Challenge Isn't Ecommerce

Online shopping has never been more convenient. Consumers can browse thousands of products, compare prices, and check out in seconds without ever leaving home. For retailers, the question is no longer how to compete with ecommerce. It's how to give people a reason to visit in the first place.

Many brands respond by investing more heavily in paid media, launching bigger promotions, or increasing discounts. While these tactics may generate short term sales, they rarely create lasting relationships. In a world where convenience is expected, simply offering another promotion isn't enough to encourage someone to step inside a store.

According to Pion's Back to School Unlocked report, Gen Z students are looking for something different. They're looking for experiences, community, and places where they genuinely want to spend time. The retailers seeing the strongest engagement aren't simply selling products. They're becoming part of students' everyday lives.

‍

The Footfall Paradox: Why More Convenience Means Fewer Store Visits

The decline in footfall isn't because people no longer enjoy shopping in person. It's because convenience has fundamentally changed expectations.

Consumers still value physical retail, but online shopping has raised the bar. If someone can buy the same product online with next day delivery, a physical store needs to offer something ecommerce simply can't.

That's where many brands fall short.

The retailers attracting Gen Z aren't asking customers to visit purely to make a purchase. They're creating environments worth experiencing. Shopping becomes a reason to connect with friends, discover something new, or spend time somewhere that feels enjoyable rather than transactional.

The challenge facing retail today isn't digital competition. It's creating experiences that justify the journey.

‍

The Third Space Advantage: Why Gen Z Is Choosing Places Over Purchases

Sociologist Ray Oldenburg introduced the concept of the third space to describe places people spend time outside of home and work. Today, that concept has become increasingly relevant for retailers trying to connect with younger consumers.

For students, home is their first space and university their second. They're actively searching for somewhere else to study, socialise, recharge, or simply spend time between lectures. Increasingly, brands have an opportunity to become that place.

Pion's Back to School Unlocked report found that:

• 95% of students feel more positive towards brands after attending an in person experience.
• 93% say those experiences encourage them to make a purchase.
• 78% want brands to continue offering in person experiences beyond Back to School.

These statistics highlight an important shift. Students aren't only deciding where to spend their money. They're deciding where they want to spend their time.

For retailers, that's a significant opportunity.

‍

How Brands Can Build Their Own Third Space

The brands creating successful third spaces consistently focus on four things: reliability, affordability, community, and experience. Together, these elements turn occasional visits into lasting loyalty.

1. Reliability‍

Students value consistency. Welcoming staff, comfortable spaces, and dependable experiences give them a reason to return.

2. Affordability‍

Student discounts, exclusive offers, and affordable treats help brands become part of students' regular routines rather than occasional splurges.

3. Community

‍The strongest brands create places where students can meet friends, study, or simply spend time. They become part of everyday life, not just somewhere to shop.

4. Experience‍

Events, creator collaborations, workshops, and interactive activations transform stores into destinations rather than transactions.

Retailers that invest in these four areas stop competing on price alone. They begin competing on belonging, and that's what keeps students coming back.

‍

The Routine Economy: Why Loyalty Is Built Between Purchases

One campaign rarely creates long term loyalty. Routine does.

Think about the places students naturally return to every week. A coffee shop before class. A gym after lectures. A retailer hosting seasonal events. A beauty store where they browse with friends.

These aren't simply places to buy products. They're places that become woven into everyday life.

Students rarely remember every social ad they scroll past, but they remember the places where they studied for exams, celebrated birthdays, or caught up with friends. Those experiences create emotional connections that transactional marketing struggles to replicate.

Instead of asking, "How do we drive more footfall?" retailers should ask a different question:

How do we become somewhere students naturally return?

Brands that answer that question successfully build loyalty long after the initial purchase.

‍

What Leading Brands Are Getting Right

Several brands highlighted throughout Pion's research demonstrate what effective third spaces look like in practice.

Hollister transformed shopping into a social experience through live DJs, product personalisation, exclusive student discounts, and interactive in store events. Rather than focusing solely on products, the brand created an atmosphere students wanted to experience together.

Starbucks has built loyalty in a different way. Its stores have become reliable spaces between lectures, meeting points for friends, and places to study. Combined with personalised rewards and student friendly offers, Starbucks becomes more than somewhere to buy coffee, it becomes part of a student's weekly routine.

Although the execution differs, both brands succeed for the same reason: they prioritise community, consistency, and experience alongside the product itself.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a third space?

A third space is somewhere people spend time outside of home and work or university. For retailers, becoming a third space means creating an environment customers actively choose to return to.

How can retailers increase in store football?

Football grows when stores provide experiences that ecommerce cannot replicate. Community events, personalised experiences, student offers, and welcoming environments all encourage repeat visits.

Why do Gen Z students value in person experiences?

Research shows Gen Z values authentic connection, community, and experiences that fit naturally into their daily routines. Physical spaces that provide these experiences become part of their lifestyle rather than simply somewhere to shop.

‍

The Verdict: From Footfall to Loyalty

Physical retail isn't disappearing. Expectations are changing.

The brands thriving with Gen Z aren't simply opening their doors and hoping customers walk in. They're creating environments where students feel welcome, connected, and part of a community. They understand that long term loyalty isn't built through one transaction—it grows through repeated, meaningful experiences.

As the retail landscape continues to evolve, becoming a student's third space isn't just a branding exercise. It's becoming one of retail's strongest competitive advantages.

Ready to discover the data behind today's most successful student retail strategies?

{{ctaLight}}